UNOPS was responsible for the biggest case of corrupt mismanagement in UN history. What did we learn from that and how do we go beyond?
28 December 2023 – Mukesh Kapila
Image by Tima Miroshnichenko, Pexels(Guest keynote at the Finnish Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Helsinki, 15 December 2023)
We live in a corrupt world. Transparency International’s 2022 Corruption Perception Index (CPI) gave the world an average score of 43 where 100 is cleanest and zero is most corrupt. Two-thirds of countries scored below 50. But congratulations to Finland: you scored 87 and rank second cleanest in the world.
But overall, the world is getting more corrupt. 155 countries have not progressed against corruption and 23 deteriorated over the past decade. Corruption appears embedded in national cultures , institutions, and body politics.
But what is corruption? According to the Oxford English Dictionary, it is the dishonest or fraudulent conduct of those in power. Usually, this is for private gain or unfair personal advantage. The World Bank estimates that corruption costs around $2.6 trillion or 5% of global GDP Plus about a trillion dollars in bribes. For some poorer countries, corruption may represent 20% of GDP apart from causing corrosive social consequences.
Why are humans corrupt? The universal phenomenon is rooted, according to psychologists, in greed and power-seeking driven by many types of insecurity, and discontent, and egged-on by peer pressure. That is not to excuse corruption but to understand the factors that increase risks. These come in many forms but why is this a development issue?
Take just one component, tax abuse. Countries lost $483 billion to global tax abuse in 2021 – enough, for example, to immunise all children. It is discomfiting that tax avoidance by diplomatically-privileged UN entities may be legal – but is it moral to deprive poor countries of much needed revenues?
Meanwhile, UNDP estimates that a quarter of $13 trillion government procurement spend is lost to corruption. And between 2000-2015, illegal money leaving Africa approached $836 billion, or 3.7% of GDP. It meant that African nations spent 25% less on health and 58% less on education. The impact is seen in higher under-fives mortality and low learning attainments. But perhaps the most notorious is corruption around the proliferation of climate action funds where hundreds of millions of dollars risk going astray. It appears that corruption is even an existentialist threat for the planet.
Corruption is also a fundamental threat to peace and security. As democracy backslides around the world and authoritarianism rises, corruption is always implicated, triggering dis-satisfaction, strife and conflict. Not surprising that conflict-torn countries such as Myanmar, Syria, Yemen, Somalia, Sudan, South Sudan score dismally at 25 points or less on the CPI scale.
I don’t need to labour the corruption -development nexus further in this audience. But with the World Bank estimating that at least 7.5% of foreign aid captured by corrupt elites, it is very relevant to development co-operation where, although Finland is small it has a big heart. Last year, you ranked eighth among DAC members with your ODA at 0.58% of GNI. I know that managing risk is taken very seriously in your aid programme.
And so it should. Your bilateral ODA focuses on Sub-Saharan Africa and South and Central Asia with a focus on fragile contexts. And these, according to the Corruption Perception Index, are corruption hot spots with, for example, Africa at 32 points on the CPI scale.
This brings us to multilaterals. In 2022, Finland allocated 53% of ODA as core contributions to them. They are also the conduit of 42% of Finland’s bilateral ODA. Most Western donors mirror this multilateral channelling.
Therefore, multilateral integrity matters. Not just because of funding volumes but because multilaterals are the norm setters, policy makers, strategy-designers and framework-providers under which other agencies cluster. In short, they monopolise the aid business.
Monopolies are always bad and how this pans out in multilateralism is best illustrated by the UNOPS case. In brief, this centres around the mis-allocation and misappropriation of around $63 million. In brief, what happened started with the top management of Executive Director Grete Faremo, a former Norwegian minister, and her Deputy Executive Director and Ukrainian national Vitaly Vanshelboim.
They started by subverting the UNOPS management structure by appointing – against mandatory human resources protocols – compliant associates to the Executive Team. As their cronies settled-in, they centralised decision-making to themselves and short-circuited internal checks-and-balances.
Thus, the technical appraisal, competitive tendering, accounting and financial procedures, risk management, audit and oversight, ethics and compliance, and protection of whistleblowers, were all undermined. UNOPS’s Chief Legal Counsel used the agency’s autonomy to construct his own laws. Furthermore, all control functions reported directly to the Executive Director who personally appointed all their heads. The world’s most authoritarian regimes could learn from Ms Faremo’s coup.
The stage was thereby set to implement a get-rich-quick scheme through a programme to build houses via a tie-up – rubber-stamped by the Financial Controller and Legal Counsel – with a shady private entrepreneur that the Executive Director and Deputy met at a party in New York, introduced by a dodgy middle-man with UN links.
When diligent staff raised red flags, they were silenced through intimidation and dismissal. The internal whistleblowing policy was completely ignored. UNOPS comes under the Secretary-General, and when staff complained to the UN secretariat’s central oversight function – the Office of Internal Oversight Services (OIOS), they were told to go away. One of the UN’s own investigators examining the complaints was himself removed from the case. Why?
Meanwhile, where did UNOPS get millions of dollars to go into business, outside of the terms of its member states approved charter? By raiding its contingency reserves against all UN rules. How did it build up a huge contingency reserve ten times greater than its Board approved limit? Through rent-seeking behaviour i.e. charging outside projects to use the UN logo and privileges in return for massive fees and over-charging for its so-called hosting service. The centre for such profiteering at expense of donors and beneficiaries was its base in Geneva. Raiding the bloated contingency reserve proceeded despite protests from ACABQ.
All this happened while the Governing Board slumbered and, indeed, commended Ms Faremo for her brilliant financial engineering. I know from my own experience when I was on such boards that most of them cannot read a spreadsheet, let alone find time as busy diplomats, to de-code the disingenuous reports – tantamount to lies – that Executive Director Faremo fed them.
Not a single house for poor people was built. That is how donors and beneficiaries were defrauded and robbed – in broad daylight – under our nose. An egregious and systematic failure. It only came to light when courageous staff provided detailed inside evidence enabling me to write about it. This was picked up by the New York Times and finally led to the Executive Director’s removal.
It was the strong position taken by Finland – alongside the United States – that forced the Board to act by commissioning studies of what happened and demanding corrective action. That included the return of millions of dollars to donors, acknowledging the rapacious behaviour of the former UNOPS management.
The UN Office of Legal Affairs – under intense pressure – has finally started some legal action. As also Finland. But the problem is that the diplomatic immunity of the perpetrators places them beyond the law. That is how high UN officials can commit crimes and get away scot-free.
This was the biggest case of corrupt mismanagement in UN history. But to give credit, UNOPS has learnt the lessons and, under new management, it is turning the corner through a corporate and governance reset. Finland has been resolute in pushing for that, using its position in the UN system and among its peer member states.
Other UN agencies – which share several of UNOPS’s institutional vulnerabilities – have been forced to sit up as, undoubtedly, the UNOPS debacle has shaken the system as a whole. A positive outcome has been to tighten up management in several agencies.
So what wider lessons can we learn? First is that generally, there is little wrong with the rules and regulations of UN multilaterals which often represent industry standards. So before tinkering with them, examine why they get breached.
That brings us to my second lesson on leadership: if power corrupts, absolute power corrupts absolutely. Unfortunately, far too many UN senior staff have their heads turned by the trappings and immunities of their exalted office. They lose sight of UN values and that they are privileged to serve the public good and not their own selves.
To keep leaders and managers honest requires independent accountability systems – so that audit, inspection, and evaluation functions are genuinely separated from the people being scrutinised.
Third, to keep oversight systems honest, requires openness and transparency. Too often, corrupted organisations and their officials hide behind secrecy. That also requires donor proactivity with their own reviews of recipients. And publishing the results. In the same way that national audit offices do with government departments. This is to overcome UN impunity – like at OIOS refusing to publish its investigation findings.
Fourth, the governance of large institutions requires professionalisation. It is no longer safe for multi-billion-dollar institutions to be overseen on an infrequent and part-time basis by untrained diplomats or aid administrators. Adequate governance oversight requires specialist skills and independent servicing.
Five, internal staff voices must be heard and protected. Institutional wrongs everywhere have only come out only when they speak up. Most staff are principled and proud to work in international organisations. Our presumption must be to believe them and investigate any wrongdoing on that basis, rather than the other way round. They are almost always proved right because risking themselves by speaking-up is not done lightly.
Six, financial corruption is just the tip of the iceberg. A corrupted organisational culture is more likely to also tolerate abuse of power in office, sexual abuse and exploitation, bullying and other misconduct. There have been many recent scandals in several agencies- not just in the UN system but also large international NGOs. Such organisations are also more ineffective and inefficient, as measured by their results and value-for-money delivered.
Seven, donors should themselves set standards. Their laxity can infect the agencies they fund. For example when a revolving door means that donor staff diligence is compromised because they want to work themselves in the agency they are overseeing. Perhaps there should be a break clause for those moving jobs this way, as is good practice in public administrations.
Eight, countries must take responsibility for the misconduct of their nationals in international service. When Grete Faremo abused her high office, she disgraced all Norwegians. And she was not the first one. The former disgraced executive director of UNEP Erik Solheim was also Norwegian. Norway – a clean country ranking 4th on the CPI – has a tradition of public office holders revolving among themselves breeding, therefore, an unholy nexus of tolerated misconduct. Perhaps that is why an embarrassed Norway has obscured the misdemeanours of its high level secondees in the international arena. Even its national media has complained.
So, it is not right to let the UN take all blame if member states do not discipline their own crooks. There must be international sanctions in such cases as, for example, when peacekeeping units misbehave, their countries may be excluded from future peacekeeping roles. The same happens by excluding from UN envoy roles those who are known to have had integrity problems or committed human rights abuses in their own countries. When it comes to corruption, how about excluding nominations from countries whose nationals have a track record of corruption in UN roles?
Nine, there must be penalty and payback – so that corruption and unethical practices are not seen as profitable. In the case of UNOPS, so far, everyone has got away with their pensions and benefits intact even if their contracts were terminated. Although, this is being challenged in the case of the Deputy Executive Director in an internal – and privately-conducted – UN labour tribunal, the outcome is far from certain.
Ten, anti-corruption elements must be integrated in all aid. Not just in governance capacity building but also in sectoral aid as for health, education, environment, and so on. These should include explicit risk appraisal, mitigation and oversight. More consumer feedback and effective complaint and redress mechanisms would help. Also more performance audits. I have seen how often agencies are their own judge and jury for their inflated results claims. For me that is a form of corruption.
Let me finish by reiterating appreciation for Finland’s principled position. By taking a stand in the UNOPS case, you sent a clear signal that corruption and misconduct cannot be tolerated. Not just for financial reasons. But also for moral reasons. Because without trust in the integrity of the development cooperation mission, we lose public support in both donor and partner countries.
Worse than that, the diversion of resources betrays the poorest and most vulnerable people we are pledged to help. The most appalling example of that was this year’s suspension by WFP of food aid to the starving people of Tigray because there had been aid diversion by Ethiopian elites.
For those privileged to work for humanity, ours is a sacred trust, and the standards to which we uphold ourselves must be higher than the ones applicable elsewhere. There can be no compromising on integrity.
But, at the same time, it is vital not to learn the wrong lesson by reducing development aid because some of it is lost through corruption. To do that would be to penalise further the most poor and vulnerable who need our help most. The perverse outcome of doing that would be to entrench – not counter – the conditions that create corruption.
Thank you, Finland, for continuing to be a generous donor – while setting and upholding high standards and raising our sights yet higher.
1 Comment
Dear, Mr. Kapila. The corruption and lying at Unops are still ongoing. Can you help?