Conversation with Michael Kohler, humanitarian ambassador and professor
Here is my latest Episode 25 of my Reviving Fading Causes podcast covering the Grand Humanitarian Bargain.
I was myself in Istanbul in 2016 for the first World Humanitarian Summit as the world’s biggest donors and aid implementers earnestly shook hands. We promised better help for the most desperate people afflicted by disasters and conflicts. Through more flexible and quicker funding with a quarter flowing directly from donors to local responders who are first on the crisis scene, and last to leave.
Ten years later, my generation’s successors, the current Grandees of the Grand Humanitarian Bargain gathered in Geneva to take stock. The score-card was embarrassing: barely 4% of humanitarian euros reach local agencies directly, with the rest still going through intermediary international organisations. This raises questions around effectiveness, efficiency, and trust in the global setup.
Meanwhile, the humanitarian system has indeed transformed. But not as we envisaged: aid budgets are slashed even as humanitarian values, standards and protections decline, and more aid workers perish at the frontlines of fast-expanding needs. 99% of those killed last year were local workers courageously serving their own communities. Have donors just transferred life-threatening aid delivery risks to locals while keeping the money that should better support them?
So, is this once noble humanitarian reform effort a dead horse? I put this to the Grand Bargain’s public face and chief persuader: Professor Michael Kohler, its Ambassador for the past three years. He is a veteran of four decades of aid diplomacy and the former acting Director-General of ECHO, the European Union’s humanitarian arm.
Michael is open on his own frustrations as he acknowledges the failures. But he points to the many good things that have happened such as the shift towards cash assistance, progress on innovative financing, and increased investment in anticipatory activities. And most of all, the table provided by the Grand Bargain is the only place where big but increasingly-humbled global donors and small but increasingly-assertive local agencies sit together as equals.
But is this clutching at straws? The Grand Bargain may have changed our language with phrases like localisation and empowerment tripping off our tongues. But is it not true that two years of severe aid strangulation has done more to shift the system’s unbalanced power structure than ten years of ambassadorial cajoling?
Michael responds with candour: what has worked, what failed and, most important, why? And his reasons for not throwing the baby out with the bath water, as we argue over underlying issues of money, power, and accountability.
Subscribe HERE to The Reviving Causes Podcast, previously The Fading Causes Podcast where earlier episodes can be found.